After six years of research, a team of scientists at the University of California, Santa Cruz has developed a cost-effective new aquaculture feed that eliminates conventional fish meal and fish oil ingredients while also providing better fish weight gain and higher nutritional value in the filet for humans. The new fish-free feed is the first to demonstrate across-the-board gains in sustainability, performance, economic viability, and human health.
Writte by: Allison Arteaga Soergel / news.ucsc.edu
“This is a potential game-changer for shifting aquaculture to more sustainable practices,” said Pallab Sarker, lead author of a Scientific Reports article on this research published Nov. 12.
Sarker, an associate research professor in environmental studies, works alongside Professor Anne Kapuscinski, a sustainability science and policy expert, to co-lead an ecological aquaculture research facility at the UCSC Farm. Their lab focuses on integrating circular economy concepts into aquatic food systems, particularly as a means of breaking aquaculture’s reliance on wild-caught forage fish for feed ingredients.
Sarker and Kapuscinski developed their new feed by replacing fish oil with whole cells from a marine microalga called Schizochytrium sp. and swapping out fish meal for leftover biomass from oil-extracted marine Nannochloropsis oculata microalga, a protein-rich waste product from commercial omega-3 dietary supplement production.
The new fish-free feed formula was then tested against a conventional feed and a few other blends in an experiment where 480 Nile tilapia were cultivated for six months. By the end of the trial, tilapia on the fish-free diet showed 58 percent higher weight gain percentages, compared to those on conventional feed. Tilapia on the fish-free diet also had the highest amount of heart-healthy DHA omega-3 fatty acids in their filets, which is a key improvement over other feed formulations currently available on the market.
“You can develop fish-free feed using soy and corn and other ingredients, but the problem is, you compromise the fatty acid profile of the filet,” Sarker explained. “Terrestrial vegetable oils lack long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, but from the combination of these microalgae, we found a higher amount of deposition from DHA into tilapia filets, which is good for human health.”
Feed produced using agricultural crops can also have an imbalance of limiting amino acids and lower palatability and digestibility, resulting in reduced fish growth. The new fish-free feed avoided these problems. Another improvement the new microalgae-based formula offers over crop-derived ingredients is that it reduces the myriad sustainability issues associated with producing agricultural products for animal feed, rather than direct human consumption. And the team’s research shows promising results for the potential cost-competitiveness of their new formula, too.
Despite some of the ingredients in the fish-free feed being slightly more expensive compared to conventional feed, the tilapia on the fish-free diet grew so efficiently that the production cost per kilogram of tilapia was actually lower for the new formula.
That outcome, in particular, is likely to pique interest across the aquaculture industry, since tilapia is one of the most popular farmed fish in the world. The insights from this successful feed formula may have applications for other species, too. Sarker and Kapuscinski now hope to leverage what they’ve learned to develop fish-free aquaculture feed for rainbow trout.
If successful, those efforts would be another major milestone, since salmonids are highly valued in aquaculture and consume enormous quantities of fish meal and fish oil. Aquaculture will need to continue expanding to support the protein demands of a growing human population, but through continued research, UC Santa Cruz scientists see an opportunity to help shape a more sustainable future in that process.
“Aquaculture is the fastest growing food sector in the world, but it’s still a young industry compared to agriculture,” Sarker said. “We have an opportunity to not make the same mistakes. This research could be a key leverage point for reforming aquaculture to ensure sustainable growth in ways that don’t damage terrestrial or aquatic ecosystems.”